Skip to content
University of East London
  • Staff login
  • Student login
  • Study

    Study

    Site Navigation - Quick Links

    • Why UEL?
    • Undergraduate prospectus
    • Postgraduate prospectus
    • Sport at UEL

    Undergraduate study

    View all of our undergraduate subjects.

    Explore now
    • COURSES
      • Undergraduate
      • Postgraduate
      • Getting back into education
      • Subjects
      • May starts
      • Apprenticeships
    • STUDENT INFORMATION
      • Student life
      • Current students
      • New students
      • Accommodation
      • Term dates
      • Fees and funding
      • Scholarships
    • VISIT UEL
      • Open days and events
      • Our location
  • International

    International

    Site Navigation - Quick Links

    • Why UEL?
    • Undergraduate prospectus
    • Postgraduate prospectus
    • Sport at UEL

    Virtual Open Events

    Need support during your admission journey?

    Attend our virtual events
    • APPLYING
      • Advice for your region
      • Pre-degree courses
      • Immigration advice and compliance
      • Transferring to UEL
      • International admission deadlines
      • Pre-sessional English
      • Malvern House pathway programmes
    • STUDENT INFORMATION
      • Accommodation
      • Term dates
      • Fees and funding
      • Scholarships
    • VISIT UEL
      • Open days and events
      • Our location
      • Virtual open events
  • Your career

    Your career

    Site Navigation - Quick Links

    • Why UEL?
    • Undergraduate prospectus
    • Postgraduate prospectus
    • Sport at UEL

    Are you an employer?

    Advertise a vacancy on our platform today.

    Get started
    • STARTING YOUR CAREER
      • Career Zone
      • Explore your career
      • Career coaching and mentoring
    • GETTING A JOB
      • Meet employers
      • Be your own boss
      • Volunteering
      • Work while you study
  • Partners

    Partners

    Site Navigation - Quick Links

    • Why UEL?
    • Undergraduate prospectus
    • Postgraduate prospectus
    • Sport at UEL

    Are you an employer?

    Advertise a vacancy on our platform today.

    Get started
    • Partnerships at UEL
    • Train your workforce
    • Share your skills
    • Connect with our people
  • Our research

    Our research

    Site Navigation - Quick Links

    • Why UEL?
    • Undergraduate prospectus
    • Postgraduate prospectus
    • Sport at UEL

    REF 2021

    Read about our Research Excellence Framework submissions and results

    Impact case studies
    • Postgraduate research students
    • Research impact
    • Partnerships
    • REF 2021
  • About

    About

    Site Navigation - Quick Links

    • Why UEL?
    • Undergraduate prospectus
    • Postgraduate prospectus
    • Sport at UEL

    Connected campus

    We are improving our three campuses for people to study, work and live.

    What we're doing
    • OUR UNIVERSITY
      • Our schools and subjects
      • Staff
      • Governance
      • Professional services
      • Vision 2028
      • Alumni
      • Accreditations
      • Sustainable Development Goals
    • TEACHING AND SUPPORT
      • How we teach
      • Mental wealth
      • On-campus nursery
    • GET INVOLVED
      • Events
      • News
    • GET IN TOUCH
      • Our location
      • Contact us
  • Home
  • About UEL

Rwanda: UK Government will be legalising trafficking of refugees

Hero Carousel

Refugees

Professor Giorgia Dona argues the Government would be carrying out formal, legalised human trafficking in its plans to process asylum seekers offshore in Rwanda 

See all our News articles

Published

12 May 2022

Share

Share On Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn

In April 2022, the UK Government announced that some people who arrive in the UK via unofficial routes, such as on small boats crossing the English Channel, could be deported to Rwanda. Their asylum claims would be assessed in the African nation and, while those who receive asylum would be able to access employment, healthcare and social services, they would have very little chance of returning to the UK.

Human rights groups have launched various legal challenges to the policy and this is why, claims the Government, the plan has not yet started to deter unofficial Channel crossings, as intended.

The Government says relocating and deporting people to a new country is a way of undermining and reducing the traffickers. But the  Government plans, in effect, replicate the trade.

They will be moving bodies across borders without their consent, under coercion in exchange for money - as the Rwandan government will receive £120 million for the pilot. This exchange of people for money is exactly what traffickers do. How is this in any way different, apart from the fact it has a sheen of legality? 

There are serious ethical and moral issues here. Human rights are being violated, both in the legal and moral sense.

According to the UN Refugee Convention, people fleeing conflicts have the right to seek asylum. While countries do have a right to deny their asylum, they must at least listen to the asylum claim. This is not simply a nicety. It is a right human right. It is a right inscribed in the Refugee Convention.

Additionally, refugees or people seeking protection should not be penalised if they travel without documents. It is understood that if you're fleeing wars or if you have to leave quickly, your passport or ID card might be left behind or destroyed. In those cases, people still have a right to claim asylum.

Another concern in terms of human right violations centres on the choice of destination country: Rwanda.

Rwanda is not the safe haven the Government would have us believe. There have been human rights violations there that even the UK Government has criticised. Rwandans still flee oppression and persecution. This includes a number of journalists and political opponents. The choice of Rwanda in terms of their human rights track record is, at best, problematic.

There is also an issue in terms of international relations and burden sharing of refugees, and the responsibility of the UK in relation to other countries. What the UK Government is doing is violating the principle of the 'Global Compact on Refugees'. Although the compact is not legally binding, there is a moral and political obligation to comply with an agreement that has been approved by the international community.

The number of asylum seekers Western countries receive is always very, very limited. Some 89 to 90 per cent of refugees end up in regions of origin. What the UK Government is doing is more like burden passing.

And, in doing so, it's passing the burden back on to a country that is economically less developed and poorer than the UK. A rich nation is subcontracting out a responsibility to protect, handing out its human rights obligations to a poorer nation to deliver on its behalf.

There are more liberal ways forward. This may include setting up more legal routes for asylum seekers from different countries, not just from Ukraine. This would reduce the need for refugees to cross the hazardous Channel undocumented.

The Ukrainian refugee crisis has shown us a way forward. If there is political willingness, along with a national impetus, the public is very receptive. We need to level up and strengthen the current response and mobilise the national mood rather than creating obstacles that exacerbate the problem and do little to save endangered lives.

The Rwanda solution not only violates our obligations to civilised human rights, but it will inevitably create a larger market for the people smugglers, defeating its aims - even on its own terms.

  • Professor Giorgia Dona is co-director for The Centre for Migration, Refugees and Belonging at the University of East London and lived in Rwanda herself, authoring books about the country.

Share

Share On Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn

Communications team

Contact us for press and interview requests

 

+44 (0)20 8223 2911
pressoffice@uel.ac.uk

Help us make this site better by telling us what you think about this page

Social Media

Follow us on social media:

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Youtube Instagram TikTok

University of East London

University Way

London, E16 2RD

United Kingdom



T. +44 20 8223 3000


Explore UEL

  • About UEL
  • Take a virtual tour
  • Calendars
  • Freedom of information
  • Governance management
  • Services and departments
  • Find us
  • Contact us

The University

  • Undergraduate
  • Postgraduate
  • News
  • Events
  • Jobs

University of East London

University Way

London, E16 2RD

United Kingdom



T. +44 20 8223 3000


Copyright ©2023 University of East London

  • Accessibility
  • Data protection
  • Sitemap
  • AccessAble
  • Modern slavery
  • Legal and compliance
  • Cookie settings
  • Privacy